Talk:Bib info: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(moved) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
* However, Zelda should be free to create a new versionmy desire to read Edgar Allan Poe's original work, should not constrict SJ's, or anyone else's, freedom to create a new version. When SJ changes "The Black Cat" he should also change the CREATOR field and make sure the [[Bundle_metadata#acknowledgments_-_required|acknowledgements]] file references Edgar's original work. We could not find a more elegant way to do this without making the format of bib_info much more complex. ---[[User:Berrybw|Bryan Berry]] |
* However, Zelda should be free to create a new versionmy desire to read Edgar Allan Poe's original work, should not constrict SJ's, or anyone else's, freedom to create a new version. When SJ changes "The Black Cat" he should also change the CREATOR field and make sure the [[Bundle_metadata#acknowledgments_-_required|acknowledgements]] file references Edgar's original work. We could not find a more elegant way to do this without making the format of bib_info much more complex. ---[[User:Berrybw|Bryan Berry]] |
||
</blockquote> |
</blockquote> |
||
This isn't a corner case; we are trying to caputre information that is usually left out of bibliographies but is citical in a world where there is active sharing editing and reuse. |
|||
Latest revision as of 18:21, 31 January 2008
Moved from the article:
- If I search for "The Black Cat" by Edgar Allan Poe, I want the original work by Edgar Allan Poe that my friends have read. I should not read to the end of "The Black Cat" to find there is a new ending added by Zelda.
- However, Zelda should be free to create a new versionmy desire to read Edgar Allan Poe's original work, should not constrict SJ's, or anyone else's, freedom to create a new version. When SJ changes "The Black Cat" he should also change the CREATOR field and make sure the acknowledgements file references Edgar's original work. We could not find a more elegant way to do this without making the format of bib_info much more complex. ---Bryan Berry
This isn't a corner case; we are trying to caputre information that is usually left out of bibliographies but is citical in a world where there is active sharing editing and reuse.