John Dvorak: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(Removed Dvorak-unrelated comment) |
|||
| (2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
John Dvorak, noted industry curmudgeon, has taken an intense dislike to the OLPC XO. Nobody knows why, because the reasons he gives in his columns don't make sense. |
John Dvorak, noted industry curmudgeon, has taken an intense dislike to the OLPC XO. Nobody knows why, because the reasons he gives in his columns don't make sense. |
||
==Dvorak== |
==Dvorak== |
||
| Line 17: | Line 17: | ||
*[http://www.fastsilicon.com/off-the-wall/pcmags-dvorak-sees-olpc-as-elitist-insult.html PCMags Dvorak Sees OLPC As Elitist Insult] 06 December 2007 |
*[http://www.fastsilicon.com/off-the-wall/pcmags-dvorak-sees-olpc-as-elitist-insult.html PCMags Dvorak Sees OLPC As Elitist Insult] 06 December 2007 |
||
Pro OLPC, not needing to reference Dvorak at all |
|||
* John Dvorak should just go ask [[Rufus]]. The experience of this ten year-old boy in England, using one of the first XO laptops, says it all more eloquently than any adult could. |
|||
* I hereby publicly challenge Mr. Dvorak to a dual: Give me an XO, a hand crank generator and a decent internet connetion. Give Mr. Dvorak $100 worth of rice (long grain, instant, puffed, or wild (his choice)). OK, $180 worth of rice. Drop us each into a remote area such as an African rain forest. Let's see who can survive the longest. This would be a dual to death - the one who lives the longest wins. I believe the old adage, "give someone a fish (or a bag of rice) and you feed them for a day; teach someone to fish and you feed them for the rest of their life", applies here. Mr. Dvorak, put your life where your mouth is - put up or shut up. What do you say, Mr. Dvorak? $180 worth of rice versus the world's online knowledge base and the world's OLPC community support. I await your reply. [Note: I am a meek and mild mannered 142 lb electrical engineer with limited survival skills, but I am VERY serious about this challenge.] --pkv |
|||
PS Feel free to invite the Chairman of Intel and Mr. Bill Gates to accompany you - they could act as your second. |
|||
Latest revision as of 16:22, 27 February 2008
John Dvorak, noted industry curmudgeon, has taken an intense dislike to the OLPC XO. Nobody knows why, because the reasons he gives in his columns don't make sense.
Dvorak
- The woeful tale of the $100 laptop The true cost of a futile effort to equip the Third World Nov. 15, 2006
Responses
Pro OLPC, anti Dvorak
- Dvorak: falling for Intel, MS, OLPC line December 11th, 2007
- Dvorak's Mind Share Shame: Junk Computers "To the surprise of some, this is where I disagree with Dvorak and actually completely agree with OLPC." Wayan Vota, November 18, 2006.
Pro Dvorak, anti OLPC
- PCMags Dvorak Sees OLPC As Elitist Insult 06 December 2007