OLPC Courseware Review: Difference between revisions

From OLPC
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(→‎Detailed Reviews: reclassify PyGeo)
No edit summary
 
(13 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 9: Line 9:
* [http://www.jeannot.org/~js/isard/ Isard]
* [http://www.jeannot.org/~js/isard/ Isard]
* [http://www.mit.edu/~ibaran/kseg.html KSEG]
* [http://www.mit.edu/~ibaran/kseg.html KSEG]
* [http://www.ofset.org/drgeo Dr. Geo, GTK+ interactive geometry]
* [http://www.ofset.org/drgeo Dr. Geo], Interactive geometry software for XO OLPC, GNU/Linux, Windows, Mac OSX


==Detailed Reviews==
==Detailed Reviews==
Line 17: Line 17:


===Interactive Geometry===
===Interactive Geometry===
⚫
;[http://www.jeannot.org/~js/isard/ Isard]:
⚫
*"only works under VisualWorks". A non-commercial version of VW is available, but requires registration. So it seems a deal would be required. The VisualWorks product manager's email is on the webpage. Perhaps Isard might be ported to squeak.
⚫
*[http://www.jeannot.org/~js/isard/IsardManual.html Manual].
⚫
*Direct manipulation + macros + smalltalk.
⚫
*Unclear if internationalized (but I haven't even looked at the source).


====Candidates====
;[http://www.ofset.org/drgeo Dr. Geo]:

*"Due to a lack of resources and time, I have decided to not maintain any more Dr. Geo. However it does not mean Dr. Geo will not evolve anymore, it is up to its users to do so. Therefore, if you think you can take over its maintenance, please do so and inform the Dr. Geo users throught its mailing list. Hilaire Fernandes, 20/10/2006". Is on sourceforge.
⚫
;[http://edu.kde.org/kig/ Kig - KDE Interactive Geometry]:
*Requires GTK and Guile.
⚫
*[http://docs.kde.org/stable/en/kdeedu/kig/ handbook].
*Manuals in Dutch,English,French,Italian,Spanish (but English is "completely out of date"). [http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http%3A%2F%2Fdocumentation.ofset.org%2Fdrgeo%2Fes%2Fdrgenius.html&langpair=es%7Cen&hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&prev=%2Flanguage_tools English google translation of the Spanish manual].
*Direct manipulation + macros + scheme.
*Direct manipulation + macros + python.
⚫
*Unclear whether internationalized or not.
⚫
*Internationalized.
⚫
*KDE's attempt to replace KSEG, Dr.Geo, KGeo(dead), etc. But seems to currently be missing much.


;[http://www.mit.edu/~ibaran/kseg.html KSEG]:
;[http://www.mit.edu/~ibaran/kseg.html KSEG]:
Line 36: Line 32:
*Internationalized.
*Internationalized.


====Disrecomended====
⚫
;[http://edu.kde.org/kig/ Kig - KDE Interactive Geometry]:
⚫
*[http://docs.kde.org/stable/en/kdeedu/kig/ handbook].
⚫
*Direct manipulation + macros + python.
⚫
*Unclear whether internationalized or not.
⚫
*KDE's attempt to replace KSEG, Dr.Geo, KGeo(dead), etc. But seems to currently be missing much.


;[http://www.cs.rice.edu/~jwarren/grace/ GRACE]:
;[http://www.geogebra.org/ GeoGebra]:
*Looks long dead. Java.
*Java
⚫
*[http://www.geogebra.org/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=blogcategory&id=75&Itemid=61 docs]
⚫
*Direct manipulation. Macros planned.
⚫
*Internationalized (at least the docs are).
⚫
*Award winning. Wiki. I tried a mandrake rpm on a x86_64 2ishGHz redhat (current). The UI was sluggish. And had minor problems (an unreadable menu). 310MB memory. Otherwise nice. Resource usage makes this a non-starter, yes?

⚫
;[http://www.jeannot.org/~js/isard/ Isard]:
⚫
*"only works under VisualWorks". A non-commercial version of VW is available, but requires registration. So it seems a deal would be required. The VisualWorks product manager's email is on the webpage. Perhaps Isard might be ported to squeak.
⚫
*[http://www.jeannot.org/~js/isard/IsardManual.html Manual].
⚫
*Direct manipulation + macros + smalltalk.
⚫
*Unclear if internationalized (but I haven't even looked at the source).


;[http://geonext.uni-bayreuth.de/ GeoNet]:
;[http://geonext.uni-bayreuth.de/ GeoNet]:
Line 57: Line 59:
*Java
*Java


;[http://www.geogebra.org/ GeoGebra]:
;[http://www.cs.rice.edu/~jwarren/grace/ GRACE]:
*Java
*Looks long dead. Java.
⚫
*[http://www.geogebra.org/cms/index.php?option=com_content&task=blogcategory&id=75&Itemid=61 docs]
*Direct manipulation. Macros planned.
*Internationalized (at least the docs are).
⚫
*Award winning. Wiki. I tried a mandrake rpm on a x86_64 2ishGHz redhat (current). The UI was sluggish. And had minor problems (an unreadable menu). 310MB memory. Otherwise nice. Resource usage makes this a non-starter, yes?


===Other topics===
===Other topics===
Line 73: Line 71:


===Synthesis===
===Synthesis===

;Interactive Geometry:
;Interactive Geometry:
⚫
:Kig(KDE) seems a locus of future progress, and is python scriptable. But it is not as featureful as others. If we need GTK, then Dr.Geo(GTK,may be dying). KSEG(Qt3) or Dr.Geo(GTK,may be dying) might be added for features. But I've not actually ''used'' any of them yet! GeoGebra is nice but probably doesn't fit on olpc. --[[User:66.30.117.127|66.30.117.127]] 13:20, 12 January 2007 (EST)
:[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_geometry_software http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_geometry_software]
:[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_geometry_software http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_geometry_software]
⚫
:Kig seems a locus of future progress, and is python scriptable. But it is not as featureful as others. KSEG(Qt3) or Dr.Geo(may be dying) might be added for features. But I've not actually _used_ any of them yet! And the wikipedia page suggests there are other possibilities worth considering! [[User:66.30.117.127|66.30.117.127]] 18:43, 9 January 2007 (EST)




Latest revision as of 17:59, 19 June 2011

This article is a stub. You can help the OLPC project by expanding it.

Introduction

There is a body of Open Source courseware that already exists. Please evaluate these programs and write a detailed review on this page. If you know of a program that should be reviewed, add it to the list.

Note that some of these existing projects may need to be ported in order to be usable. For instance changing the GUI from KDE to GTK. Please note this in the reviews.

Courseware to be Reviewed

  • Isard
  • KSEG
  • Dr. Geo, Interactive geometry software for XO OLPC, GNU/Linux, Windows, Mac OSX

Detailed Reviews

package

details

Interactive Geometry

Candidates

Kig - KDE Interactive Geometry
  • handbook.
  • Direct manipulation + macros + python.
  • Unclear whether internationalized or not.
  • KDE's attempt to replace KSEG, Dr.Geo, KGeo(dead), etc. But seems to currently be missing much.
KSEG
  • Requires Qt3.
  • manual.
  • Direct manipulation + macros. No programming language.
  • Internationalized.

Disrecomended

GeoGebra
  • Java
  • docs
  • Direct manipulation. Macros planned.
  • Internationalized (at least the docs are).
  • Award winning. Wiki. I tried a mandrake rpm on a x86_64 2ishGHz redhat (current). The UI was sluggish. And had minor problems (an unreadable menu). 310MB memory. Otherwise nice. Resource usage makes this a non-starter, yes?
Isard
  • "only works under VisualWorks". A non-commercial version of VW is available, but requires registration. So it seems a deal would be required. The VisualWorks product manager's email is on the webpage. Perhaps Isard might be ported to squeak.
  • Manual.
  • Direct manipulation + macros + smalltalk.
  • Unclear if internationalized (but I haven't even looked at the source).
GeoNet
  • Java
  • Internationalized? ENglish-ification of the website doesn't seem to be working, so its hard to tell how much is available in other than german.
  • Linux installers (with and without jre) failed on an up-to-date x86_64 redhat. No rpms.
  • Looks interesting, and rich. But java.
C.a.R.
  • Java
Gambol
  • Java
GRACE
  • Looks long dead. Java.

Other topics

PyGeo
  • 3D "Interactive" Geometry
  • 3D (may be a performance issue?)
  • Python programatic interface. No direct manipulation for construction. (Someone needs to write a GUI wrapper;).
  • Interesting in its own right, but not a competator for an olpc "interactive geometry" package.

Synthesis

Interactive Geometry
Kig(KDE) seems a locus of future progress, and is python scriptable. But it is not as featureful as others. If we need GTK, then Dr.Geo(GTK,may be dying). KSEG(Qt3) or Dr.Geo(GTK,may be dying) might be added for features. But I've not actually used any of them yet! GeoGebra is nice but probably doesn't fit on olpc. --66.30.117.127 13:20, 12 January 2007 (EST)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interactive_geometry_software
Retrieved from "http://wiki.laptop.org/mediawiki/index.php?title=OLPC_Courseware_Review&oldid=257256"