Repair centers

NOTE: The contents of this page are not set in stone, and are subject to change! This page is a draft in active flux ... Please leave suggestions on the talk page.

This is a community-run effort. The content on this page is not necessarily produced or endorsed by OLPC or its employees.

This is a plan and proposal for a future repair centers program which does not exist yet because supply solutions have not yet been worked out. You can help us.

These are draft discussions. Please feel free to comment, contribute, add, etc. to any section.

Meetings

A few semi-spontaneous discussions have been held on IRC, and future talks will likely take place in the #olpc-groups channel. Hang out there if you are interested, or contact Mel Chua if you'd like to gather the community and schedule a time for everyone to talk and share ideas - we haven't had formal meetings yet because there isn't enough information for very concrete plans to be formed, but as supply-chain solutions and repair center business plans grow in number and solidity, that may change.

Meeting minutes

• /Jan 27 2008

Assumptions

• "Repair centers" can refer to individuals, schools, nonprofits, companies... any group interested in helping people get their XOs fixed.
• Repair centers can charge, be free, whatever they want financially.
• Repair centers do not get marching orders or funding from OLPC-the-nonprofit. (Financial and logistical independence.)
• Repair centers are an educational process; things other than financial/process efficiency also matter.

Program goals

• Minimize shipping
• Minimize bottlenecks
• Minimize necessary infrastructure - "we're in business to put ourselves out of business"
• Maximize user control and choice
• Maximize available service
• Encourage peer to peer repair support - "repair local act global"
• Any given XO owner should have at least 3 different routes to repairing their laptop, including fixing it themselves. (Corollary: tools for repair should be available, as well as parts.)
• Anti-vandalism repair program design - make it hard to cheat people and easily for anyone to track down and correct it, without putting legal/financial responsibility on OLPC itself.

Legal stuff

• OLPC is not liable for anything repair centers do. The burden is on repair centers and users to understand the legalities behind repair-related liabilities in their country.
• We should get volunteers to research and compile guides to relevant legal information for various countries repair centers might be starting up in (do this on the public wiki).
• We must make it clear to potential repair shop starters/workers that they will be held responsible if they break stuff; OLPC can't help them.

Rights and Will Nots

OLPC will not

• prevent independent groups from setting up their own certification processes as long as repair centers are not forced into using them and they are clearly marked as not being official OLPC certifications (please reword this; it's klunky.)
• restrict access to new or reconditioned parts

Repair center rights

• You have the right to start up, operate, and close down when and how you wish.
• You have the right to privacy; you do not need to advertise, be listed, or share information about yourself with anybody in any way.
• You have the right to choose your credentials. OLPC does not have or endorse an official repair certification, but you may choose or create a certification system yourself as long as it is clearly marked as not an official OLPC certification. (please reword; klunky.)
• You have the right to make a profit in a way that does not obstruct the rights of others, including XO users and other repair centers.
• You can offer and charge for any services you wish, including repair programs, warranties, etc. but it is your legal responsibility to handle and fulfill them financially and otherwise.
• You have the right to serve whom you please, and to turn down jobs you don't want. (For instance, a repair center may restrict itself to only serving children from a particular school, or decide to specialize in display problems only.)

Repair centers CAN NOT:

• have an exclusive territorial or other monopoly over any user group
• directly hinder or prevent any other repair center from operating

User rights

Inspired by the Maker Bill of Rights

• You are free to obtain parts and service from any person or group you wish.
• You are free to fix your laptop yourself; you do not have to go to a repair center if you do not want to.
• Buyer beware.

Repair center paradigms

1. Ship part to user, DIY repair
2. Ship part to user, user looks up repair centers in some directory, contacts them individually for help
3. User looks up local repair centers in directory, contacts them directly to order parts and get help
4. User ships XO to repair center, repair center ships back a working XO immediately for a flat rate, repair center gets parts and fixes broken XO then adds to "working XO" stack
5. (variant of above:) Different centers specialize in different parts - when a user sends in a broken laptop, that part of the laptop gets replaced with a working part, and the broken part is repaired (or if complicated, sent to the specialist). When repaired, the part goes into the working-parts pile.
6. User ships XO to repair center, repair center gets parts, fixes laptop, ships same XO back to user
7. User contacts SG, SG walks them through diagnosis with a help@ RT ticket, when they figure out what's wrong user is pointed towards instructions or local repair centers
8. After-school XO repair class/program, students (not necessarily limited to kids) fix XOs for "homework"

Financing paradigms

1. OLPC sponsors/certifies nobody and does not run its own "official repair shops" (although it will probably provide some helpful resources, hints, and gathering places for repair centers to use). Each repair center is financially and logistically on their own.
2. If OLPC offers parts at a premium, and also offers a 'pedigree', repairs could become a donation source. This requires OLPC to manage, support, finance, and assume legal responsibility for such a program, though.

Business plans

Have a business plan model for how repair centers can run? Talk with one of the Repair center locations about how to apply it to their specific situation, or post your ideas here.

• Business plan model - post ideas here!
• Business plan model - post ideas here!
• Business plan model - post ideas here!

Issues under debate

Official certification debate

"Official certification" refers to an "official" OLPC-administered certification (possibly with training) that repair shops can get.

PRO:

• Keep people from getting ripped off by scam artists
• Community recognition and respect
• Nice to have an "I'm good at this!" badge

CON:

• Bottleneck; "We're in business to put ourselves out of business"
• Paper does not determine talent - possible to forge
• Independent groups can and will set up their own cert processes so we don't have to; see http://wiki.laptop.org/go/Content_stamping.

Copycat parts

Discussion opinion on this topic was split, and the final answer needs to be determined by OLPC and its partners.

Everyone agreed that copycat/unofficial parts would happen, and shouldn't be unilaterally stopped. There was disagreement on whether there should be "official" and "unofficial" parts (as "quality guarantees") or requirements/recommendations for manufacturers to make their parts traceable back to them (legal/copycat concerns vs users being able to track/recommend particular parts to each other).

• What components are open/not-open in terms of licensing and design?
• Does OLPC or its pratners have any issues with people designing, producing, and selling copies of existing XO parts?
  • Will there be any "official" OLPC parts or products, and if so, how will they be identified?
  • Are there any ID/logo/branding or source identification/disclosure rules they should follow or avoid?
  • What will be encouraged, discouraged, and enforced?
• Does OLPC or its partners have any issues with people designing, producing, and selling other (non-copycat) XO parts/accessories?
  • Are there any ID/logo/branding or source identification/disclosure rules they should follow or avoid?
  • What will be encouraged, discouraged, and enforced?
• How does this work with international patents/trademarks/copyright laws?

Resources needed

This is a list of resources OLPC and the OLPC community might consider creating.

• Tech documentation to go off teamwiki onto public (mchua: It's unclear what further documentation is needed; please list specific stuff we need access to but don't have and we can try to get access to those in particular.)
• A place where all repair centers can list themselves ("Yellow Book") and be reviewed (separately?)
• Sample repair contract templates for download and use - completely optional, but encouraged for people to keep track of repairs they do or have done.
• A place/way for people to upload the aforementioned repair contracts, so that a neutral third-party has records that can be accessed in the event they're needed.
• Suggestions for ways repair centers can track and organize their information
  • Templates/examples on public wiki
  • http://openplans.org
  • "RT for repair centers" guidebook (and offers of free hosting)
  • other solutions?
• Repair info on laptop libraries
  • a page with instructions for repair, as in Disassembly]
  • "User's Bill Of Rights" informing them that they can hack their laptop and choose who to entrust it to, and tips on how to be smart about it
  • A page on what part designs are/aren't open, and where the open part schematics are available (should also be available online)
  • A link to the repair centers info page
• On the public wiki: a grassroots-maintained resource on any legal issues involved with running a repair center, manufacturing/selling parts, etc. for various countries

Getting parts

Supply chains

What can we do? What are different models for getting parts out to centers?

• Brightstar is shipping central?
• Megafranchise model
• Independent hackers and their small companies (a-la adafruit, sparkfun)
• Community "XO Labs" also serve as repair centers

Availability

• Both new and reconditioned parts should be available.
• There should not be "One Righteous Source" for parts - people can buy and sell parts to each other privately, as always.

How you can help

We need action, but first we need ideas that can be put into action, since repair centers can involve the complex and costly shipping of parts across the world, and we'd like to minimize this whenever possible and discuss it in advance. Some specific things we're looking for are below.

Business plans

We need "business plan" proposals for individual repair centers themselves - which can only be generated by the folks who want to run those centers, as each situation is different. What will you do, how will you run both logistically and financially, where will you get resources and what resources will you have, what services will you offer to whom, and so on. Note that it may be a few months before we're ready to have other repair shops join the fray, but we can certainly start preparing. Add your group to the Repair center locations list, get in touch with an existing repair center group directly with feedback, or generate ideas for business plans and post them here.

Supply chain solutions

We need to find a way to deal with the financial, shipping, and legal logistics behind repair centers getting parts - wide-scale donations (even of broken machines) to any repair center that wants them isn't a scalable/sustainable solution. There's also the tough balance of ensuring repair centers are run by good people doing good work without imposing onerous "certification" burdens on either the repair centers or OLPC itself (which doesn't have the resources or the desire to be the Big Boss behind all these repair shops) - again, any help in coming up with models and solutions for this would be super-welcome. Add your thoughts on the discussion page.

Collaboration models

A number of global/grassroots communication and collaboration models among repair shops so that they can share ideas, parts, refer customers to each other, and so on. After generating a strawman business plan for your center, you may want to get in touch with one of the other centers-in-the-making and hash out ideas together for how two entirely different repair centers - or more! - might be able to work with each other. Get in touch with Repair centers directly, or add your thoughts on the discussion page.

Situational adaptations

The situation in the US with G1G1 and small, privately-run pilots is also rather different than the situation in the countries that the "give one" laptops are rolling out to en masse. One is the availability of parts (and transport to ship things in and out) and the proportionally higher "real cost" of parts as a significant expense to XO users not in "Get One" households. Another is saturation of laptops in an area and how that affects supply and demand - if 15 centers in Chicago want to open repair shops, but only 100 laptops exist in the entire metro/suburban area and most of those are with developers who can usually repair their own, what can centers do? Local pilots in "Get One" areas will change the saturation situation drastically - how will community groups react? Add your thoughts on the discussion page.

Doing more than just repair

Repair centers don't have to just do repairs, they can do other things that require physical equipment like peripheral/hardware/charger etc. design, community gathering places... becoming a physical meeting point for local Grassroots groups. What else can you think of? Add your thoughts on the discussion page.

Existing proposals

Infrastructure suggestions

• Local Coordinator with Backup
  • From our current volunteers, support and otherwise

• Location: University, Church or Other NonProfit
  • Must have secure onsite storage for equipment , tools and parts
  • Must have shipping/receiving capabilities during "normal business hours"
  • Must be able to accomodate 30+ people plus parking
  • Must *not* require additional insurance waivers etc
  • must have broadband available: ethernet to set up temporary hotspot

• Times: Regular Periodic
  • At least monthly
  • As often as weekly, or more, if staffing and demand supports it

• Atmosphere:
  • Model on Apple Genius Bar? eg. make it an showcase for OLPC and the XO
  • Setup Hotspot
  • Setup Mesh
  • Allow drop ins to mesh their XO's
  • Snacks etc if volunteered
  • really great POS from OLPC
  • A few demo XO's for folks to try

• Repair:
  • DIY supported
  • Knowledgeable volunteers to help

Other resources

• Volunteer repair centers being formed around the US
• Interactive XO Support Forum Interactive Community Based Tech Support Group

Discussion on repair centers can be found on the talk page. Also see the pilot repair center going up at Boston-area Olin College as a first testing point of the infrastructure - more sites to follow.